Peer-Review Workflow and Policy
Peer-Review Process
Journal of Education for Humanities and Applied Sciences )Faculty of Education - Al-Khums, Elmergib University) is dedicated to maintaining the highest standards of academic integrity, scholarly excellence, and objective evaluation. The journal strictly enforces a Double-Blind Peer-Review System, where the identities of both authors and reviewers remain mutually concealed throughout the entire review lifecycle. This approach ensures unbiased, equitable assessments grounded solely in intellectual merit, originality, methodological validity, and substantive scientific contribution.
Step-by-Step Review Workflow
The review and editorial process proceeds through the following phases:
1. Initial Submission & Editorial Screening:
Upon submission via the online journal platform or official editorial email, the editorial team conducts a preliminary desk review to verify alignment with the journal’s aims and scope, adherence to the Author Guidelines, and compliance with the permitted plagiarism/similarity threshold.
2. Reviewer Assignment:
Manuscripts successfully passing desk screening are anonymized and assigned to at least two external, independent peer reviewers selected on the basis of their subject expertise, scholarship, and track record in the respective discipline.
3. Double-Blind Evaluation:
Reviewers independently evaluate the manuscript according to standard academic criteria: originality, relevance, conceptual clarity, methodological rigor, data validity, soundness of discussion, and bibliographic integrity. Reviewers submit detailed evaluation forms with actionable remarks and explicit recommendations.
4. Editorial Deliberation & Adjudication:
The editorial board reviews and reconciles the reviewers' evaluations. In the event of substantially discordant recommendations (e.g., one acceptance and one rejection), the manuscript is submitted to an independent third reviewer for final arbitration.
5. Decision Notification:
Based on the compiled review outcomes, the editorial board renders one of the following decisions:
o Accept without revisions.
o Accept subject to minor/major revisions.
o Decline/Reject.
The corresponding author is notified in writing, receiving a consolidated, fully anonymized copy of the reviewers' critiques and revision directives.
6. Revision & Re-evaluation:
Authors required to revise must submit their modified manuscript alongside a point-by-point response letter addressing all reviewer queries within the specified timeframe. Revised drafts are re-examined by the editor or returning reviewers to confirm satisfactory compliance.
7. Final Acceptance & Production Scheduling:
Upon successful fulfillment of all editorial, methodological, and formatting specifications, an official Letter of Acceptance is issued, and the article is queued for layout typesetting and publication in an upcoming journal issue.
The Journal of Education for Humanities and Applied Sciences remains committed to an expeditious, transparent, and rigorous peer-review schedule, safeguarding publishing efficiency while upholding uncompromising editorial standards.